Saturday, March 5, 2016

Superdelegates weren't elected because they support Clinton

Here' a graphic you'll never see on cable TV news . . .

Actual pledged delegates 2016 Dem Primary March 5

PETITION TO ALL SUPER-DELEGATES: "I support Bernie Sanders, but I will not Support Hillary Clinton in a general election."

To defend the skewed delegate count in the Democratic primary, the argument is currently being made that the voters elected superdelegates, and by proxy, they have also agreed to support Hillary Clinton. This is a totally false argument, because many (if not most) of the current superdelegates were elected long before Bernie Sanders or Hillary Clinton had even announced their run for the Presidency.

Bill Clinton is a superdelegate who was campaigning for his wife inside a polling location in Massachusetts — and Bernie Sanders lost that State by a mere 1.48% (50.11% to 48.69%).

FiveThirtyEight: Superdelegates might not save Hillary Clinton, but they could tip the balance to her in a close race. If you’re a Sanders supporter, you might think this seems profoundly unfair. And you’d be right: It’s profoundly unfair. Superdelegates were created in part to give Democratic party elites the opportunity to put their finger on the scale and prevent nominations like those of George McGovern in 1972 or Jimmy Carter in 1976, which displeased party insiders. Here’s the consolation, however. Unlike elected delegates, superdelegates are NOT bound to any candidate, even on the first ballot. They can switch whenever they like [any time between now until the DNC convention held in late July]. And some of them probably will switch to Bernie Sanders if he extends his winning streak into more diverse states and eventually appears to have more of a mandate than Clinton among Democratic voters. Hillary Clinton knows this all too well; it’s exactly what happened to her in 2008 during her loss to Barack Obama.

Current Democratic Super-Delegates: Voters didn't vote these people into office years ago because they support Hillary Clinton today in 2016:

20 distinguished party leaders (current and former presidents, vice-presidents, congressional leaders, DNC chairs)
21 Democratic governors (including territorial governors and the Mayor of the District of Columbia)
46 Democratic members of the United States Senate (including Washington, DC shadow senators)
193 Democratic members of the United States House of Representatives (including non-voting delegates)
437 elected members of the Democratic National Committee (including the chairs and vice-chairs of each state's Democratic Party)

Media Over-Emphasizes Hillary's Super Delegates

If you watch cable TV news (i.e. CNN, MSNBC, etc.) you'll see that they keep flashing these huge graphics on the screen showing Bernie Sanders lagging far behind in the delegate count with Hillary Clinton. There's a reason for this: The mainstream media is trying to kill the grassroots enthusiasm for Bernie Sanders, to make him look less "electable", and to sway voters to vote for Hillary Clinton. And what is that reason? Because Bernie Sanders would raise taxes on these very same corporations and their CEOs (and because the corporate media would prefer Clinton by far over Donald Trump).

From my previous post: Is the Corporate Media Rigging Elections? >>> Media CEOs dominate the ranks of the highest paid executives. Six of the 10 highest-paid CEOs worked in the media industry. The six corporations that collectively control 90% of U.S. are AOL/Time Warner, Walt Disney, Viacom, Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp. (Fox News, etc.), CBS Corporation and NBC Universal (owned by Comcast).

As an example, Comcast owns MSNBC, and the VP of Comcast held a fundraiser for Hillary Clinton and donated to her campaign. And when the progressive MSNBC host Ed Schultz blasted Hillary Clinton for her support of the TPP trade deal, it ended up being his very last show on MSNBC. Quinky dink? The major media corporations support the TPP trade deal — the trade deal that President Obama wants. And Hillary Clinton is running on continuing Obama's policies. After supporting this trade deal 45 times, she has only recently said she against it — but that's only because Bernie has been steadfastly against it from the very beginning, as he's been against Bill Clinton's trade deals as well. It's almost guaranteed that Hillary Clinton will find some reason to support the TPP trade deal if she is ever elected President.

Here is exactly what Hillary Clinton told Nevada political reporter Jon Ralston in a TV interview on June 16 last year about fast-track (TPA) and the program for re-training displaced workers (TAA) and the Asian trade agreement (TPP). Hillary Clinton only opposes the current TPP trade bill if it excludes the funding for re-training displaced workers. She clearly seems to support both the TPP trade deal and fast-track, and is only taking a stand on assistance for displaced workers — which, at best, is only a mediocre program that does very little for millions of workers who lose jobs to foreign low-wage countries or to those who come here on guestworker visas (such as H-1B)

Despite the recent attention Bernie Sanders has been receiving in the mainstream media, it's not to benefit him. The cable news shows seem to find more pundits that are critical of him than who favor him, and many times don't provide equal time to Sanders' supporters. Just prior to Super Tuesday there was a media blackout of Bernie Sanders as thousands of his supporters marched in 45 cities. We didn't see this on Fox News, MSNBC or CNN. The mainstream media is not just reporting news, they are actively trying to influence the election to benefit themselves. If one watches very closely, the cable news networks sometimes do this in a very clever and nuanced way, such as complimenting Sanders for his honestly and authenticity, while also claiming that his ideas are too radical and not pragmatic.

As for delegates: 458 of Hillary Clinton's "delegates" are actually superdelegates -- i.e., party insiders who support whoever they want. When you only count the number of "pledged delegates", Clinton and Bernie are running a fairly close race. Clinton has 608 pledged delegates to Bernie's 410 — with 3,267 delegates not yet allocated — and 2,383 delegates are needed to win the Democratic nomination. Bloomberg (updated March 5, 2016) Hillary Clinton: 1,066 (includes 458 superdelegates) / Bernie Sanders: 432 (includes 22 superdelegates).

Below is a recent example for Colorado as reported by the Denver Post: Bernie won big, but because of "super-delegates", is only projected to tie Hillary in delegates because of the superdeleagtes.

Bernie Sanders - Denver Post

Also, besides over-emphasizing the super-delegate count, the media also keeps emphasizing that labor unions are backing Hillary Clinton: Not true. It's only the labor union's "leaders" who are endorsing Clinton. Whenever it's put to a vote to a union's rank-and-file members, the actual workers overwhelmingly support Bernie Sanders. That may be because of Bernie's stand on trade deals that offshore the best-paying jobs, or because of his stand on guestworker visas that use foreign labor to displace American workers for lower wages — trade deals and visas that Hillary Clinton mostly supports — i.e. NAFTA, PNTR for China (that her husband signed) — and until recently, the Triple Trade Treaty Threat: the TransPacific Partnership (TPP), which is expected to come to a Congress this fall. That will be followed by the TransAtlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) and the Trade-in-Services Agreement (TiSA).

Just as Hillary does, so do the big banks support these trade agreement (YouTube: Hillary Clinton's claim about no bank is too big to fail and no executive is too powerful to jail.)

Hillary Clinton Goldman Sachs CEO Lloyd Blankfein


  1. Here's one Democratic superdelegate:

    Florida Representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz is fighting for payday lenders in Congress, instead of protecting working families. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is about to release new rules to rein in the predatory payday industry, whose sky-high interest rates are designed to trap vulnerable people in cycles of debt. But Wasserman Schultz is rallying support in Congress for a new bill that would gut these rules. Why? Maybe it has something to do with the more than $68,000 in campaign contributions she has taken from the payday industry.

    * Everything that Bernie Sanders is against and Hillary Clinton is for (but only now says she's against).

  2. Foreign-Born New Hires Outpace Native-Born

    Job creation from January 2007 to December 2016

    3,070,000 Foreign-born workers added / Source: St. Louis Federal Reserve (FRED) Foreign born workers
    + 2,358,000 Native-born workers added / Source: St. Louis Federal Reserve (FRED): Native born workers
    = 5,428,000 Total net jobs added to labor force over the past 9 years

  3. Campaign ad: Bernie Sanders on Trade Deals

    For Jobs, For Us | Bernie Sanders

  4. March 5, 2016 -- Washington Post:

    Sanders has a good chance to win caucuses in Nebraska and Kansas on Saturday .. and he is also likely to win a caucus Sunday in Maine. But Clinton is likely to prevail in the Louisiana primary by a wide margin the same day — and that would make her still come out ahead on the delegate math, said campaign manager Robby Mook. "We have no doubt that as long as Senator Sanders remains in the primary, he will continue to win elections along the way, but it will make little difference to Hillary’s pledged delegate lead."

    * Short commentary: I can't stand that pompous little @hole.

  5. State-by-State Delegate Distribution

    *It's seems difficult two find two websites that agree on the actual number of pledged delegates.

  6. I’m watching election results right now -- and on CNN (and especially on MSNBC) they keep reminding us that despite Bernie’s wins tonight (Kansas and Nebraska), Hillary still has all the super-delegates.

    During her speech tonight, Hillary reminded us that within the next 4 years, one or two more Supreme Court Justices might die, so we’d better elect her to make the most sensible choice for replacing them.

    I think Bernie Sanders can nominate Supreme Court judges too . . . what do you think?

  7. Bernie wins Kansas and Nebraska.

    Clinton dissed the great State of Maine, declaring after her Saturday win in Louisiana, "now all eyes turn to Michigan."

  8. UPDATE: As promised...

    7th Democratic Debate: Best Recaps not on Cable News

    The best 26 most relevant minutes of the 7th Democratic debate on March 6, 2016 in Flint, Michigan.
    There are two separate videos, each 13 minutes long, embedded at the bottom of this post.
    They include many highlights that they aren't showing on the cable news stations (CNN, MSNBC and Fox News)
    Fighting the media black out of Bernie Sanders



  9. Bernie Sanders, in a historical upset, just beat Hillary Clinton to win the State of Michigan yesterday.

    There are 4,763 total Democratic delegates
    - 770 super-delegates
    = 3,993 regular delegates (allocated by primaries/caucuses)

    2,383 delegates are needed for the party nomination
    - 770 super-delegates
    1,613 outstanding regular delegates needed for nomination

    Excluding super-delegates, regular delegates allocated so far as of March 90, 2016:

    Clinton 760
    Sanders 546

    Super-delegates can change their mind any time up until the DNC convention in July. If the don't vote with the popular vote, that could spell big trouble for the political insiders (and Bernie could even run as an Independent -- or his supporters would write in his name -- or they would vote Republican -- or they might not vote at all.)

    But the media (especially on the cable news stations) are always totaling the delegate count with the super-delegates to make the election appear as though it's already a done deal for Hillary.